Baseball:

Ryan Castle - 1992
Bob Henshaw - 1994
Danny Connolly - 1997
Laz Carrasco - 2000
Fabio Ricci - 2014
Justin Cassinelli - 2014
Steven Figueroa - 2015
Austin Pollack - 2016 (Academic & Athletic)
Scottie Giordano - 2018
Tommy Poggi - 2024
 

Men's Basketball:

Dick Meister - 1959
Allen Thompson - 1975
Kurt Alston - 1978
Wendell Owens - 1981
Bashkim Mustafaj - 1991
Michael Campbell - 1994
Jarrod Famous - 2009
Keith Thomas - 2014
Tremaine Fraiser - 2018
 

Women's Basketball:

Sheila Henderson - 1983
Porsha Postell - 2010
Jessica Biggs - 2011

Bowling:

Dennis Light - 1993, 1994
Eric Kattenhorn - 1995
Sabreenia Hill - 1997
Steve Jusino - 1997
Ralph Devarti - 1999, 2000
Jessica Kasper- 2023

Golf:

Mitch Glicksman - 1991
Joe Del Grosso - 2004

Soccer:

Michael Whelan - 1970
Michael Whelan - 1971
Patrick Anderson - 1972
Ralph Maceria - 1972
Michael Whelan - 1972
Ralph Maceria - 1973
Carlos Cardenas - 1974
Miguel Maceria - 1974
Liam McGlone - 1978
Victor Pacheco - 1979
Calvin Balfoun - 1980
John Rudovic - 1981
Sean Kenny - 1982
Ed Langort - 1982
Laurence Piturro - 1988
Rickland Hudson - 1992
Michael Mcspedson - 1994
Roldan Sanotoria - 2000
Almar Selimi - 2002
Guilherme Griza - 2018
Demoni Gordon - 2024
 

Softball:

Denise Jones - 1980, 1981
Barbara Swanson - 1980

Wrestling:

Doug Wager
Rob Weiner - 1979